U.S. Bancorp Mortgage Complaint

U.S. Bancorp Mortgage department,

Conventional fixed mortgage Loan modification,collection,foreclosure California

We are a HUD approved foreclosure counseling agency and we are working with a client to try to get her loan modified. We submitted a work out package and have had issues from this company in getting this file for review, giving us one excuse after another as to why this is not moving forward. At one point I was told by one of the representative that it was not unusual that it was taking so long that it could take up to a year ( a prior complaint was sent on this company to CFPB ). We recently received a denial letter stating client did not qualify for any modification program. They listed the NPV test that failed, as the reason for their denial stating that they could not come up with a payment within the program guidelines. This was for both their standard modification and the Home affordable modification. After reviewing their denial letter and the vague explanation for denial I proceeded to perform my own calculation using the figures they had provided. I also performed another NPV test again using most of the information they provided and the result form the NPV test I performed was positive and it state the client may qualify. My concern is that this file is a rather difficult file since the client has rental income as her primary source of income and other outside the box issue that this company did not do a accurate and complete review of this file. I believe a experience and knowledgeable underwriter needed to be the one assigned to this file as they would have been better equipped to understand how to underwrite. Also looking at the way this file started and the issues we have had since the inception of this review, I question the commitment this company has had to truly assist this client. I feel that it has been demonstrated through their action that they may have used whatever excuses to deny my client instead of working to approve.